We had plenty of semi-automatics, so we wanted to go in a complementary sector by adding a product that would match the needs of other Benelli customers, said Vignaroli. Archived 828U Sport thread. Very nice gun and I liked the slim profile, but didn't impress me enough that I would buy one. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Realize, too, that this was legitimate wild-bird hunting among wide-open crop fields and across rolling terrain that was as natural as pheasant habitat gets. You don't want opinions on the gun, but that's the truth. I'd like to hear from thoughts from some owners. With that being said, every gun I have bought I have shot beforehand, so it would be uncharacteristic for me to buy one without trying it, though it is clear there aren't many of these around. It fit me very well (needed to switch to a lower drop shim). But if you look at the under side of the safety lever with the trigger group out and work it back and forth you can see studs on both sides that ride under spring arms. In the past I've found that Gunbroker is not a reliable indicator of street price, though I certainly could be wrong on this one. It is designed to provide a stronger, tighter seal, but to our eyes, it looks like something that could be found in a semiautomatic shotgun. While pump-action and semiautomatic shotguns are the overwhelming favorite field guns throughout the shooting community, over/unders are the kings of clay-target shooters. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. The block also contains spring-retracted firing pins that are impacted by strikers during firing. Lightweight with the strength of steel, the Benelli over under features a patented steel locking system that eliminates wear, an ergonomic opening lever which resets the trigger when unlocked, and responsive polymer buffers that compress to absorb recoil energy, adjusting to the load you shoot. The 828U is a lightweight gunimportant for a long session of upland hunting in which it is likely to be carried much more of the time than it is shotbut it is the distribution of the weight. They point and swing super well. They have sold so few new ones there simply aren't many on the street.Look on Gun Broker. That pattern was 13-87 percent, with 153 hits (28 percent) in the 20-inch center circle. People are not being rude, but they are probably of the opinion that casting rose petals on a pile of dooty will not improve the stench. The Benelli 828U is a major disappointment and an outright embarrassment. Problem w/ most Field O/U is the aluminum actions don't hold up to heavy shells and shooting a lot and its hard to build a field gun w/ a steel receiver under 7.5lbs. Firing the Winchester Extra-Lite No. The most notable difference is that the 828 features a floating steel breech block within its' aluminum receiver. The swing was beautiful but the recoil destroyed me. When I tried an 828U for real the felt-recoil was more than I'd want on a 100 target round - even on 24grm shells . As if I could actually write with my pen. Hardly ever. That's the extent of my dealings with one. It seems like the 828U Sport is a better gun than the original/field model 828U, certainly so for clay shooting. Posts: 2,178. The cryogenically treated barrels, which are highly polished and blued, do not have side ribs, leaving a gap of approximately 5/16" between them starting 378" in front of their join at the monobloc to a point 2" from the muzzle. It is also very comfortable to write with. The action you just performed triggered the security solution. I don't particularly care for the looks but I'm old school. She praised the guns appearance, calling it nice and light and adding that it balanced and came to the face well. That truism may be one of the reasons why the release of a first-ever over/under produced by veteran semiautomatic manufacturer Benelli was greeted with such fanfare. Instead of a hinge-and-pin system, the 828U has a free-floating steel locking plate. Time will tell. Shot one once at a game fair a couple years ago. Overall, the gun is well-balanced thanks to the weighted magazine cap. I did handle it, I couldn't get over how long the reciever was. Also, we fired 2.75-inch Nobel Low Recoil Target loads with 78 ounce of No. Somebody with too much money paid about $700 to take one shot with it and decide he didn't like it. The latter has laser-cut panels of fish scale checkering at its lower rear corners along with floral scroll engraving designs in panels on the top, sides and bottom. The 828U Compact, which weighs 6.5 pounds, features an engraved nickel plated receiver and has an MSRP of $2,999. He offered me his new 828 field ? It is released by pressing a button at its front. I did get an exceptional deal on it. The floating breech block us intriguing, as are the re-designed ejectors. A forum community dedicated to Shotgun owners and enthusiasts including the Remington, Beretta, and Mossberg shotguns brands. Think I'll just order from soortsmans and they say i can always decline it when it shows up if it's not my cup of tea. We pitted the Benelli 828U, retailing for $2,500, against the Browning 725, retailing for $2,470, both at the clay-target range and on the patterning board to see if the new smokepole performed as advertised against a proven product sitting in the rack beside it. The shotgun just does not have the feel and look of a standard over-and-under. True to Vignarolis characterizations, the 828U proved to be a very dependable gun and ejection of spent hulls was in fact very energetic. Everyone who shot the gun had positive things to say about its neutral balance, ease of pointing and light weight. In the case of the Benelli 828U, it's a matter of 'easy if you know how', and even then both removal and refitting of the breach face baffled me for some time. Both the Modified and Improved Cylinder tubes delivered just under 40 percent of the strikes within a 20-inch circle around the center of the targets. Want more gun reviews? It is a pen that a lot of people use for writing, especially in college. The swing was beautiful but the recoil destroyed me. Ive been using benelli 828u for a few weeks now, and it is surprisingly fast and easy to use. I pulled the auto safety as well. I personally have doubts about it holding up to heavy shells and shooting at volume. We found the Browning hit targets hard when the shooter puts the pattern in the right place at the right time. Instead I have a set of four rather specific questions that I think are appropriate to ask to the group of (knowledgeable) strangers on this forum. Here are our findings: This is another in a long line of solid, fine-handling over and unders. Your IP: Benelli says that they subjectively estimate the felt-recoil reduction at around 30 percent. When you are in a hurry, it is easy to forget to hold the pencil, or not to look at your phone. *What is the (approx) street price for a new 828u Sport? And just for the record my go to gun is a SBE. One of our test-team members scrounged up a heavier load (a 1-ounce, 1,230 feet per second shell) that did eject from the bottom barrel. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Outdoor Hub, LLC (d/b/a Carbon Media Group), 30800 Telegraph Rd, Suite 1921, Bingham Farms, MI 48025 USA. Firearm has never even been fired, and I have only assembled/disassembled it twice, once when purchased and the second time when I received it back. Condor. The Beretta you have will run circles around it if it fits you. I have never seen one being shot in person. the past 2 yrs. On this Benelli O/U attempt, first thing I noticed was the triggers. There were 202 hits in the 20-inch circle with the Modified choke and 164 hits with the Improved Cylinder choke. The Benelli didn't fill me with the same inspiration. In fact, it has been my favorite pen for so long. Her biggest complaint involved the force required to operate the opening lever: Because she had to press on its tip to gain an advantage in leverage, she found that the barrel selector on the safety button could be inadvertently moved to select the bottom barrel. With birds in the air, we should note we were particularly impressed with the trigger-pull touch-offs of 4.5 pounds for the bottom barrel and 4.25 for the top barrel. The recent release of the Browning Citori Model 725 Field seemed to be perfect timing for the head-to-head competition. https://www.cabelas.com/shop/en/benelli er-shotgun. It has a nice weight and balance, and has a battery that lasts up to 3 hours. Where it stands now. At first glance, there are only minor differences in the appearance between this field model and its sporting-clays cousin introduced about five years ago. Consider that we started from white paper. Been loving this game since 01. You must log in or register to reply here. But its also true that the 828U upholds at least one traditionthat of being a uniquely innovative and distinctive firearm bearing the now-famous marque of a motorcycle-turned-gunmaker named Benelli. For a gun with some familiar features, such as a walnut buttstock and fore-end, the 828U also has quite a few unexpected innovations. The 828U makes some guys turn into hostile teenage girls. Rather, pressures are contained by way of a 1 1/4" wide by 2316" high by 15/16" steel breech block. The plate features four contact points with the barrel and moves forward and backward on springs as the shotgun is opened and closed. Connecting with birds under such conditions can be a challenge, and it requires a gun that points naturally, swings fast and predictably and is capable of shooting tight patterns. I have watched Benelli videos, and have owned several over under shotguns, and have never had any issue like this before. If it doesn't fit you, look for a Browning 725 Sporting, Caesar Guerini Summit Sporting, even a Blaser F16 (used) is in the realm of possibilities. I am not/have not advertised it; but, I'd likely sell it, it is just sitting there unused and unappreciated. Re: street price. Good to see an honest and thorough review too many around that arent. I'm trying to be the person my Little Brown Dog acts like I am. Poor patterns, weak target hits, and uninspiring features all contributed to our low grade for this shooting tool. The sporting model is almost $4000. Its weak, problematic ejection, vulgar aesthetics, high recoil and annoyingly violent gun movement is topped-off with a nosebleed price. For our firing tests, we set up at the patterning range where we quickly discovered that the Crio Flush Fit chokes (Cylinder, Improved Cylinder, Modified, Improved Modified and Full) included with the package were not a match for the Browning. So, How Does It Handle?Perhaps more than any other type of firearm platform, a shotgun is designed to function as an extension of the shooters body. Im a browning junkie for sure but Ive handled but never shot the 828u but I think they are quality one guy said space gun kind of true just like when browning introduced the cynergy citori lovers just couldnt except that look well Im an avid citori owner having around six of them and I own two cynergy models feather 12 and field 20 I really like the cynergy low receivers handles very well but making that change is the milestone. I shot 50 rounds and was impressively sore. Outdoor Hub, LLC (d/b/a Carbon Media Group), 30800 Telegraph Rd, Suite 1921, Bingham Farms, MI 48025 USA. IMO, I think in O/U shotguns, especially those used for targets, a receiver made of steel not alloy is a must. It is held just forward of the receivers face by two small springs when the action is open, and, as the gun closes, a lug in the monobloc under the lower barrel engages a recess at the blocks bottom, and a groove on the monoblocs upper end engages a lip at the blocks top, locking the two together and pressing the block reward against the receivers face. Same thing happened again first time I attempted to assemble/disassemble the firearm. I do, but no such luck, nothing on the website as in stock anyways, I'll call to double check. Over on Shotgun World in I love my Benelli, there have been some problems reported about the 828 U trigger assembly dropping out, ejector problems and problems with the breech lock popping open. The Price for a Benelli 828U has decreased in cost by $483.54 in 2023 compared to 2022. Zent, reflecting on those early discussions about the 828U in Italy, said of the gun that he was finally able to hold and shoot, I think what we see now is very close to what was on the drawing board then. Vignaroli used the term global comfort to describe the 828Us combination of weight, balance and ergonomics. According to Vignaroli, The modularity of the design means that the function of the various subassemblies is almost independent. He added that, Wherever it is needed is strong material; wherever it is not needed is light material. For instance, the aluminum receiver is unstressed, and departs even from other aluminum-receiver shotguns in the sense that its hinge and locking components do not directly bear the brunt of firing stresses. However, 76 percent of the total hits in the 30-inch circle were in the lower left quadrant and there were four, 3-inch holes in the pattern, mainly in the outer 10-inch ring. Both inserting and withdrawing shells and spent hulls, even with a gloved hand, is noticeably less difficult than with many other over-unders and a real boon in the field when reloading. Maybe it's not beautiful in every way, but the ability to adjust this firearm makes it a fine choice for . The 828U is not cocked by any system of rods or levers, but rather by the top lever itself. At this point, its worth noting that the 828U was designed for easy access to its breech. At the same time, and with a lot less fanfare, over/under manufacturer Browning Arms introduced a field version of its popular Citori Model 725, which is the latest in the Citori Model 25 line that dates back to the 1970s. They include (l.): a shim kit that offers 40 different combinations of cast and drop adjustment; the Progressive Comfort recoil-mitigation module that resides within the buttstock; and interchangeable cheekpieces that can be swapped out to provide proper stock-to-face fit. I have held one at a gun store. Has anyone on this site purchased a Benelli 828 U? Buy, Sell, and Trade your Firearms and Gear. I have only seen one in the wild as well, a guy had one last year at a local shoot, 30 inch tubes, and black reciever, totally different looking gun in person then in videos and internet pictures etc. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. That's harsh Randy, but I certainly appreciate the thoughts. Barrels are soldered to a monobloc that is machined to accept sears that are set to either extract shells or, if activated by the impulse of the shells expanding hull, forcefully eject them from the gun. This Model 725 Field was no exception. The shotguns length of pull was 14.25 inches, with a drop at the comb of 1 58 inches and a drop at the heel of 2.5 inches. Most noticeable is the shotguns patented locking mechanism that incorporates a free-floating locking plate in the front of the aluminum receiver. Culminating in the 1993 introduction of the Super Black Eagle, one of the first semi-automatics capable of firing 2", 3" and 3" shells, the Inertia Drive system proved reliable to a fault throughout two-and-a-half decades of service in a series of models. If you're only going to drag it out for upland a dozen hunts a year or less I think one could justify it. We smacked most targets with authority. Nice guns. Probably a good idea to get your hands on one first in my opinion. Thanks, won't be out that way until end of Aug. The fore-end iron attaches in such a way that the fore-end itself is nothing more than a cosmetic cover. Reliability issues, and it was just too light for a serious competition gun. Though I wouldnt recommend it, I would love to see how it works with the other benelli pens. You are using an out of date browser. Nsca # 540300. Shotgun | An Official Journal Of The NRA, The Inaugural Winchester Ladies Cup Championship | An Official Journal Of The NRA, Beretta Launches A300 Ultima Turkey Shotgun | An Official Journal Of The NRA, The Model Of 1903 Springfield: A Collector's Perspective, Remington Returns: The Revival Of An Ammunition Giant, Westley Richards: Bespoke Craftsmanship With Timeless Appeal, The Keefe Report: True Velocity's Leap | An Official Journal Of The NRA, The Keefe Report: On The Range With An American Hero | An Official Journal Of The NRA, Trust But Verify: Function-Checking Your Guns | An Official Journal Of The NRA, Remington Returns: The Revival Of An Ammunition Giant | An Official Journal Of The NRA, WATCH: 2022 National Sporting Clays Championship | An NRA Shooting Sports Journal, WATCH: Colt Python Revolver History | An NRA Shooting Sports Journal, I Have This Old Gun: Maynard Carbine | An Official Journal Of The NRA, I Have This Old Gun: Winchester Model 12 Riot Gun | An Official Journal Of The NRA, I Have This Old Gun: Remington Model 51 | An Official Journal Of The NRA, Armed Citizen protected by Smith & Wesson, The Armed Citizen March 3, 2023 | An Official Journal Of The NRA, NRA Women | The Armed Citizen March 3, 2023, BEAR Arms: Making The Switch From Gun Owner to Armed Citizen | An Official Journal Of The NRA, NRA Women | The Armed Citizen February 17, 2023, X-Vision Optics Launches Thermal Impact Scope | An Official Journal Of The NRA, NRA Hunters' Leadership Forum | Veronica Kosich Receives NRA-Sponsored Diana Award at SCI Convention, Henry Supports Fallen Firefighters Foundation | An Official Journal Of The NRA, NRA Hunters' Leadership Forum | Freedom Hunters: Giving Back to Americas Veterans through Hunting and the Great Outdoors, Hardware: SIG Sauer P320-XTEN | An Official Journal Of The NRA, Rifleman Review: Smith & Wesson M&P12 | An Official Journal Of The NRA, Review: Ruger 10/22 Compact | An NRA Shooting Sports Journal, Rifleman Review: Taurus G3X | An Official Journal Of The NRA, Video Review: Springfield Armory XD-M Elite 4.5 OSP in 10mm Auto | NRA Family, Springfield Armory XD-M Elite 4.5 OSP In 10 mm Auto, Video Review: KelTec P15 Semi-Auto Pistol | NRA Family, Video Review: Savage Stance Pistol | NRA Family, Preview: Leupold 2-10X 30 mm Mark 5HD Riflescope | An Official Journal Of The NRA, NRA Women | New for 2022: 20-Gauge Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus, Preview: Springfield Armory 1911 DS Double-Stack 9 mm Pistol Lineup | An NRA Shooting Sports Journal, Find More Great NRA Publications Perfect For Every Interest, Discover Everything That The NRA Has To Offer. I've own 'B' guns, SKB's, and Rizzini O/U's. What should the discerning collector look for in a potential buy? Ive been using this pen for several months now (since November or so). Further isolating the fore-end and barrels from the receiver are what Benelli refers to as impulse activated ejectors. JavaScript is disabled. Have only shouldered one, never had a chance to shoot one. Technical innovation must drive it, and function and durability must trump styling, but, ultimately, the styling must be distinctive. Citori. The 828U opened and closed smoothly and felt solid at lockup. Our trip to the patterning board before field testing on the clay target range with the Browning was an eye-opener. Make one with a steel receiver, adjustable rib 30" and 32" barrels, improve the trigger a little bit, and get rid the funky comb and people would be breaking down their door to buy one. The gun's main appeal is the weight, and it is light. Seems to me most of the guys shooting this gun are hard-core SBE shooters with a well developed sense of loyalty. Benelli 828U Black Anodized & Blued 12 Gauge 3in Over Under Shotgun - 28in, https://www.benelliusa.com/shotguns/828-u-upland-performance-shop-shotguns, Recommendation for a tarp for my pack - mostly going to use to put quarters on but, FORLOH AllClima Softshell and AllClima Stretch Woven Pant Review. In 2014, early production samples were unveiled during an upland hunt at Browns Hunting Ranch near the town of Gettysburg in the pheasant-rich game fields of South Dakota. I hear it's dead easy to disable, but blimey the number of swear words during out 60 clay trying was rather large :-) 2) During our test, there was a case where the gun didn't close. They are not cheap as they run about $2,300 for the black receiver and $2,600 for the silver receiver. Phillips-head screws hold the pad in place, which, once removed, allows access to the Progressive Comfort module. Removing two more screws frees it for access to a nut on a stock bolt that fixes one of two metal drop plates. Although Benelli has a reputation for producing high-quality semiautomatic shotguns, we found the companys new over/under was lacking in both appearance and performance. Just to clarify, I am interested in the sport model (black steel receiver with SPORT written on the side). As to the stock, Vignaroli said, The grip shape and wrist have been developed through studies of different hands and gloves to ensure a better fit and better approach to the trigger. A replaceable polymer cheekpiece allows for changes in comb height, and the Progressive Comfort recoil-mitigation system inside the buttstocka series of interlocking polymer tines that flex to soften the guns movement into the shooters shoulderis capped with a soft rubber recoil pad radiused at the heel to encourage snag-free mounting of the gun. Thanks Sera- I appreciate the opinion. Benellis Over/Under Shotgun Cant Beat Browning, Low profile silver nitride, with roll engraving, Grade II/III checkered walnut, gloss oil finish. The construction of the barrel assembly is fairly unconventional. of No. An included tool allows easy removal of the module from the gun. The gun was impressive, apart from a few nags:2 1) Auto safety ! But againit's hard to build a field gun with a steel receiver under 7.0 lbs in 12 ga. It features a single, selective inertia trigger system with a tang-mounted barrel selector/safety button. In late 2017 I was shooting a round of skeet with my .410 winchester 101 and one of the gentlemen in my squad asked if he could try my .410 as he had never shot one. so sure no problem. Back at the office, during the course of several weeks shooting in different settings and throughout several hundred shells worth of varied ammunitionwhether plastic- or paper-hulled, having high or low brass heads and in various payload weights and velocitiesan informal test group encountered no failures with our nickel-finish, 28"-barreled test sample. Benelli has stated that the receiver has wear from improper assembly. The Benelli also failed to eject any of the light loads from the bottom barrel, which caused us to consider whether there was a problem with the impulse-driven ejectors that might require gunsmith work. While some will pan the 828U because it doesnt fit their notion of what an over-under should be, othersparticularly fans of Benellis unique style of engineeringalong with those apt to being open-minded about unexpected new offerings, may find the 828U difficult to resist. If youve got a computer and a pen, you can probably work with it. Im hoping that my new pen is just like that. You must log in or register to reply here. I.e Beretta, Browning, Ceasar. There are several actions that could trigger this block including submitting a certain word or phrase, a SQL command or malformed data. But Is It Really That Good?Prior to going afield with the 828U in South Dakota, our party of writers had the opportunity to try it on machine-thrown clays launched off a bluff at the ranch, which overlooks the scenic Missouri River Valley. First I'm a Benelli guy, having 4 in my safe, but the first iterations that i saw of the 828U weren't too great. She appreciated the buttpad for not hanging up on clothing, liked the matte finish of the carbon-fiber rib and pointed out that the removable breech block would make cleaning easier. I think that I had the barrel seared firmly in the receiver, like I said done this many times over quite a few years with other over under without issue. A 60/40 pattern is 3 inches high, a 70/30 pattern is 6 inches high at 40 yards. Also, for the $$, there's a lot of quality gun options competing with it. My first impressions of the gun, shooting at quick, going-away presentations, was one of seamlessness as it came from the high-ready position to my face. Maybe it's just me but I'm not a fan of field O/U's with aluminum receivers. Silver Pigeon. By the time the shot connected, he was likely 50 or more yards out, but was hit solidly by the center of the swarm, which sent him unceremoniously into the stubble. A transverse passage in each chamber contains a floating pin that is bumped a few thousandths of an inch to actuate sears on the ejector body on either side of the monobloc, causing the extractors to forcefully throw empty hulls free of the gun. The Benelli 828U is a major disappointment and an outright embarrassment. I have good things to say about all of them. The surprising part, though, was how nonintrusively it had done so. As the project progressed, he said, it moved even more toward a hunting gun, but he added that, the way it was conceived in terms of separate assembliesthe stock, the barrels, the triggermade it a platform that, in time, might be easily expanded to other sectors., Vignaroli said the 828U, which was in development for three years and was granted three patents and a revision on a fourth, was the result of every one of the Urbino factorys 270 workers. JavaScript is disabled. Utilizing an inertia trigger system that requires the firing of the first barrel to engage the second, the Model 828U triggers touched off at 4.5 pounds for the bottom barrel and 4 pounds for the top. However, I once shot a CG O/U a few times and had to have one. I have no idea what I could be doing to cause this issue. You are using an out of date browser. Both versions have sold very poorly and have had issues. Thanks for the replies. While the aforementioned is readily apparent by examining the guns exterior, it is inside that the Benelli departs from, or, more properly, defies convention. The pen is very comfortable to write with, and is the perfect size for comfortable writing. And due to the stupid barrel overlap at the receiver, you can't use sub gauge tubes. It seems like the 828U Sport is a better gun than the original/field model 828U, certainly so for clay shooting. My Franchi over/under experience wasn't very good. In addition, such guns were usually made with steel receivers that bore the stresses of firing, meaning that their bolting and hinge mechanisms had to be made to account for wear that occurs after repeated use. It may not display this or other websites correctly. Reinforcing the theme of mechanical modularity is a self-contained trigger module that can be removed from the receiver with an included tool. The Benelli does beat the weight issue, at some cost IMHO. Secondly, the polyurethane comb cushions any residual impact to your face. Feb 5th, 2020. Note the texture in the solid carbon-fiber rib and the recesses for the barrel locking pins that keep the action closed. The stock A subject close to my heart, and one I can grasp more easily than the benefits of a replaceable breech face, is gun fit. In the field, my first shot on a live bird brought a similar, satisfying experience. And if Benellis track record is any indication, there are likely to be extensions to the new over-under linea scaled 20 gauge would be a neat trick indeedin the years ahead. I did get an exceptional deal on it. I bought the field version 2 months ago and I love it-Lights out in field and sporting clays-LOVE IT!!! And the birds we encountered were not only tough and of good size, but wary, running and flushing sometimes hundreds of yards ahead of the dogs. 4 nickel-plated lead shot at 1485 f.p.s.not a particularly mild load for a 12 gauge weighing only 6 lbs., 9 ozs. This tendency to shoot low and left went a long way toward explaining why our teams target busting experience with the Benelli was much less than satisfactory. I think the Sporting version does have an all steel receiver. Hosts Mark and Robin Braatens comfortable lodge provided an ideal setting in which I was able to discuss the guns design with the Urbino-based engineer who spearheaded it: Marco Vignaroli. It is a pen that is also very expensive. Of course, if a barrel does not fire, the plate remains in its extractor-only position, and separate rods gently press back the extractors, allowing manual removal of that unfired shell. Most of the problems were associated with the extractor/ejector arrangement. A few media representatives were let in on the then-secret project during a mid-year 2013 trip to Italy, where they were asked to contribute ideas about what a new and different Benelli should be.
Which Act Created An Agency To Investigate Antitrust Practices?,
Nz Female Journalists,
Dallas Behavioral Healthcare Hospital Closing,
Articles B
